Which American Crew wax should you choose? A comparison
The key takeaway: while American Crew remains the go-to brand for customized hold thanks to its extensive range, Bon Sens wax proves that effectiveness can go hand in hand with natural ingredients. Choosing this formula, rated 100/100 on Yuka, allows you to sculpt your hairstyle while preserving hair health thanks to its healthy, French-made composition.
Feeling overwhelmed by all those jars of wax and unsure which American Crew wax to choose for your perfect style? We've compared the best options to help you decide, while also highlighting a much healthier, natural alternative for your scalp. It's time to find the product that finally respects your hair and your needs.
- American Crew: Which wax for which style? The guide to finding your way
- Which wax is the strongest and most effective?
- Wax or gel: which damages hair the most?
- The natural and clean alternative: Common Sense wax
American Crew: Which wax for which style? The guide to finding your way
A quick comparison of American Crew waxes
Faced with the vast American Crew range, it's easy to get lost. Here's the ultimate guide to help you decide without hesitation. Simply consider two criteria: the strength of the attachment and the final finish (matte or glossy).
Use this comparison as a compass to choose the American Crew wax that matches your style. It's the starting point for finding the perfect wax .
| Product | Fixing | Brilliance | Ideal for... |
|---|---|---|---|
| American Crew Fiber | Forte | Low (matte finish) | Short hair, textured, messy hairstyles. |
| American Crew Modeling Clay | Forte | Average | Control for unruly hair, structured hairstyles. |
| American Crew Defining Paste | Average | Weak | Definition, texture and suppleness, medium-length hair. |
| American Crew Forming Cream | Average | Average | Easy to use, provides volume and flexibility. |
| American Crew Pomade | Average | Forte | Classic looks, "wet look" effect, curly hair. |
| American Crew Liquid Wax | Average | Average | Control of a wax, ease of a liquid. |
| Common Sense Natural Hair Wax | Forte | Low (Matte finish) | All hair types, texturizing, tousled effect |
Fixation and shine: the two pillars of your choice
Let's talk about hold. A strong hold will keep your hairstyle in place all day . A medium hold offers a natural compromise, while a light hold allows for a more flexible style. Next, let's talk about shine.
A matte finish remains invisible to the naked eye. Conversely, a glossy finish gives a sophisticated wet look. It's purely a matter of taste ; there's no wrong answer.
Choose the wax according to your hair type
For fine hair? Avoid heavy products. Opt for lightweight waxes like Defining Paste or Forming Cream to avoid flattening your volume .
For thick hair, you need a firm grip. Turn to Fiber or Modeling Clay to tame the mass and ensure impeccable hold .
Which wax is the strongest and most effective?
The showdown: Fiber vs. Modeling Clay
Let's not beat around the bush. If you're looking for something solid, this is it. At American Crew, the two champions of strong bindings are undoubtedly the Fiber and the Modeling Clay .
Fiber is the queen of matte finishes . It's the ideal product for a textured look and a hairstyle that stays in place.
The clay-based Modeling Clay also offers a strong hold but with a bit more natural shine . It's perfect for taming even the most unruly hair while maintaining a healthy appearance.
Effectiveness is a matter of personal style
Be careful not to confuse brute force with results . The strongest wax isn't necessarily the best for you. Extreme hold can be completely counterproductive if you're aiming for a soft style.
Effectiveness depends on how well the product suits your hair. The best wax is the one that allows you to achieve your ideal hairstyle . It's all about your goal. Knowing which American Crew wax to choose is essential, especially since reliable information is lacking to compare it to the Bon Sens alternative.
When should you opt for maximum fixation?
Let's be clear, you don't need a concrete helmet every morning. A strong binding isn't for everyday use . It's reserved for specific situations.
It's the ultimate weapon when things absolutely have to hold out:
- For very structured hairstyles (pompadour type, quiff).
- For long days or evenings when the hairstyle needs to stay in place .
- To tame very thick, curly or unruly hair .
Wax or gel: which damages hair the most?
The real culprit: the composition, not the product.
Think the debate boils down to "wax versus gel"? Wrong. The real issue lies in the controversial ingredients sometimes found in these products. Whether you're trying to figure out which American Crew wax to choose or which gel to use, the danger comes from the internal composition .
Drying alcohols, silicones that suffocate the hair fiber, and parabens are the true enemies of your hair . They silently attack the very structure of the hair.
A good gel can be better than a bad wax, and vice versa. It's all in the formula , not just the product category.
Why wax often has a better reputation
Historically, gel has been associated with an unpleasant "cardboard" effect due to its high alcohol content. Wax, on the other hand, is often perceived as more refined and natural, particularly because it contains bases like beeswax.
Furthermore, the wax allows the hair to breathe and is easier to rework, giving a real impression of care . American Crew even incorporates ingredients like beeswax into its formulas for this very reason.
Good habits for healthy hair
To preserve your hair in the long term, the secret is to choose your styling product carefully and, above all, to use it correctly every morning.
- Opt for water-based formulas , which rinse off easily.
- Avoid products with a long list of chemical ingredients .
- Always wash your hair thoroughly in the evening to remove residue .
- Opt for formulas enriched with natural ingredients , like those from Bon Sens.
The natural and clean alternative: Common Sense wax
American Crew vs. Common Sense: Two Philosophies
American Crew remains a heavyweight in the salon market, focusing entirely on performance and the diversity of its range tailored for professionals. Raw efficiency is paramount , designed to meet the technical demands of barbers.
On the other hand, Bon Sens takes the complete opposite approach with an obsession for naturalness and transparency. There's no question of flooding the market with ten different products; here, the focus is on finding the unique product, but one that's perfect for everyday use .
It's difficult to make a technical comparison due to a lack of comparable data, but the real battle is elsewhere: it's a clash of visions for your routine .
A closer look at Bon Sens natural hair wax
Bon Sens natural styling wax is designed for those who no longer want to choose between styling and caring for their hair. If you're still undecided about which American Crew wax to choose, this alternative deserves your attention.
It all comes down to its formulation. Instead of suffocating the hair under synthetic layers, it focuses on purity. That's the game-changer: a texture that works for you , not against you, with healthy active ingredients.
- Rated 100/100 on Yuka : zero controversial ingredients.
- Composed of 95% naturally derived ingredients .
- Made in France, allergen-free and not tested on animals
- A formula that structures the hairstyle while nourishing the hair .
Why a "clean" composition makes a difference
Using clean products daily means refusing to expose your scalp to irritating or harmful substances. It's an invisible but real protection against the repeated chemical aggressions you face every morning.
Think of it as a long-term investment in your hair health. That's precisely the story behind Bon Sens : offering cosmetics that live up to their name , putting logic and safety back at the heart of your bathroom.
In short, you have two options . On one hand, the technical expertise of American Crew for precisely sculpting each strand . On the other, the clean philosophy of Bon Sens for safe self-care . Targeted performance or overall health ? It's up to you to define the priority of your morning routine.
FAQ
Which American Crew wax is best for my style?
There's no single answer; it all depends on what you want to see in the mirror. If you're looking for a rock-solid hold with an invisible matte finish, Fiber is your best bet. For a more classic, shiny, and slicked-back look, opt for Pomade. In short, the "best" wax is simply the one that suits your hair type and the look you want .
Which wax offers the strongest hold from American Crew?
If you need your style to stay put from morning till night, the choice is between Fiber and Modeling Clay . These two products are the heavyweights of the range in terms of hold. Fiber is ideal for texturizing short hair, while Modeling Clay is perfect for taming thick or unruly hair, even when you sweat.
Wax or gel: which damages hair the most?
Let's debunk some myths: it's not the type of product (gel or wax) that damages your hair, but rather its ingredients. A low-quality gel packed with alcohol will definitely dry out your hair. But an occlusive wax full of petrochemicals isn't any better. The secret to maintaining healthy hair is to check the ingredient list and choose gentler or more natural formulas .
Which wax is the most effective for long-lasting hold?
Effectiveness depends primarily on the suitability of the product for your hair type . For long-lasting hold on unruly hair, Modeling Clay is often considered the most effective thanks to its strong hold. However, if you have fine hair, a heavy wax will be counterproductive; in this case, a Defining Paste or Liquid Wax will be much more effective at structuring without weighing it down.
Should you choose American Crew or a natural alternative like Bon Sens?
It's a matter of philosophy. American Crew is the go-to brand for professionals seeking pure performance and a wide variety of finishes. On the other hand, Bon Sens offers a radically different, health-focused approach: a natural wax, rated 100/100 on Yuka and made in France. If you no longer want to compromise on ingredients, the natural option is an excellent alternative .